Deepen the Mind and Widen the Heart

On Taking Children at Their Word: Agency, Responsibility, and Epistemic Harm

Children in the Civil Rights Movement

Michael D. Burroughs, Assistant Professor of Philosophy, Director Kegley Institute of Ethics

Friday, February 9th, 3:00pm ~ Humanities Complex, HUM 1109

Recent discussions of epistemic injustice have increasingly highlighted ways in which children, alongside other social groups, are subjected to forms of epistemic prejudice and related harms. As important as these discussions are, a problem arises when we take seriously the implications of these authors’ claims, namely, that children are credible epistemic agents. Recognizing agency in children supports our listening to them as testimonial agents and their greater inclusion as members of an epistemic community. But this inclusion and attribution of agency ostensibly commits us to attributing responsibility to children for their speech and related acts, whether virtuous or vicious, good or bad. The problematic aspects of this commitment become clear, for example, when we are facing a young child who authors ignorant, disturbing, and even violent, hate speech that does harm to others. In this and related cases, we are left with a quandary: on the one hand, we want to respect the epistemic agency that children possess; on the other hand, extending this respect also leaves us in the uncomfortable and, at least in some cases, counterintuitive position of holding young, developing children, responsible for actions that they do not fully understand, or for consequences that they do not appreciate. In this talk, I will survey current attempts to address child-centered epistemic harms, while also presenting the complexity at hand in respecting and taking children at their word. I argue that children present a special case for us in our considerations of epistemic injustice – they both merit respect as persons possessing epistemic agency and, at the same time, can be harmed by related attributions of epistemic responsibility. We need a better, more nuanced understanding of child epistemic agency that will help us to make sense of this tension, and that will have implications for our understanding of other domains of child agency (e.g. moral and political agency).

About us

In both Philosophy and Religious Studies, students learn to grapple with the great questions of human existence, explore the world’s various systems of belief, and examine their own values. As a result, students develop valuable skills in critical thinking, reading, and writing, and they learn how to use these skills to solve real-world problems.

CSUB offers a Bachelor of Arts (B.A.) degree in Philosophy and a B.A. in Religious Studies.

The Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies also sponsors a number of public lectures, conferences, workshops, and publications to encourage the ongoing discussion of religious, philosophical, and ethical issues.

Please click on the links at left for more information about Philosophy and Religious Studies at CSUB.

Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies

California State University, Bakersfield
Humanities Office Building (HOB) 230
Mail Stop: 10 HOB
9001 Stockdale Highway
Bakersfield, CA  93311-1022  

Tamar Anthony, Department Administrator
Phone: (661) 654-2291
Fax: (661) 654-6904

Philosophy Fact Sheet

Philosophy Factsheet

Religious Studies Fact Sheet

Religious Studies Fact Sheet

Check Out The Philospohy & Religious Studies Club Newsletter created in Fall 2016

Philosophy & Religious Studies Club Newsletter