CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, BAKERSFIELD
Department of Nursing
NURSING 444 - Professional Nursing Practicum
Winter Quarter, 1999
FACULTY: Peggy Leapley, Ph.D., RN, CS - Office: RNEC 107 - Telephone: 664-3110
CREDITS: Lab 4 (12 50-minute clock hours). Seminar 1 hour (50-minute clock hour).
COURSE DESCRIPTION:
Integration of prior nursing and support course content into professional nursing practice. Faculty select, with student input, a clinical agency for an advanced clinical experience. Student will apply all nursing roles (clinician, educator, researcher, and leader), with an emphasis on the leader and clinician roles.
PREREQUISITE/COREQUISITE: Nursing 357, Nursing 490
REQUIRED: A CSUB health clearance, CSUB malpractice insurance and current healthcare provider CPR card must be documented on the first day of class.
COURSE OVERVIEW:
Nursing 444 is one of the CSUB Department of Nursing senior capstone courses. Student learning experiences are planned so that knowledge gained in earlier nursing courses can be integrated into a fabric of professional nursing practice. Faculty select, with student input, a clinical agency where an advanced clinical experience is planned. Faculty negotiate with an agency preceptor so that the student practicum is planned to facilitate students achievement of course objectives.
The student describes progress in meeting course objectives by submitting response/reflection communications to faculty on a regular basis. Individual and group conferences enable students to share experiences, validate observations and contribute to their own and colleagues professional development. A major written paper is the vehicle used for the student to plan, implement, and evaluate a leadership/management project, drawing on content from earlier nursing courses.
Course Objectives: Upon completion of the course, the students will be able to
1. Perform nursing roles (clinician, educator, researcher, and leader) at a beginner level of independent professional nursing practice while utilizing the CSUB Department of Nursing Conceptual Model.
2. Incorporate legal and ethical responsibilities into each of the nursing roles (clinician, educator, researcher, and leader).
3. Collaborate with other members of the multidisciplinary team to promote client (individual, family, group, aggregate, or community) system stability.
4. Utilize nursing research in the professional nursing practice setting.
5. Apply critical thinking and evaluation skills of a beginning professional leader and advanced beginning clinician in the practice setting.
6. Demonstrate professional behavior as described in specific codes of nursing practice, agency, and departmental policies.
7. Conduct a leadership/management project relevant to the practice setting.
8. Communicate findings of the leadership/management project to a professional group and faculty.
9. Demonstrate the ability to successfully pass the RN license examination (NCLEX) by evidence of RN license or an acceptable score on a nationally normed test of licensure content.
TOPICAL OUTLINE:
Plan a small scale leadership/management project
Use research skills in planning the project
Disseminate project findings to a professional group and faculty
Practice clinical leadership
Develop independence in professional clinical practice
Demonstrate legal and ethical responsibilities for ones practice
Perform nursing roles at a beginner or advanced beginner level
Demonstrate potential or actual success in passing NCLEX
TEACHING METHODOLOGY:
Guest speakers
Seminar
Clinical Practice
Plan a leadership project
Present project (oral and written)
Student reaction/reflection papers
REQUIRED TEXT:
American Psychological Association (1994). Publication manual of the American Psychological Association (14th ed.). Washington, DC: Author.*
Benner, P. A., Tanner, C. A. & Chesla, C. A. (1996). Expertise in nursing practice: Caring, clinical judgment, and ethics. New York: Springer.
CSUB Department of Nursing (1998). Undergraduate nursing policy handbook. Bakersfield, CA: Author.*
McCloskey, J. C. & Grace, H. K. (1997). Current issues in nursing (5th ed.). St. Louis, MO: Mosby.*
Sullivan, E. J. & Decker, P. J. (1997). Effective leadership and management in nursing (4th ed.). Menlo Park, CA: Addison-Wesley.*
RECOMMENDED TEXT:
American Nurses Association. (1985). ANA Code for Nurses. (Pub. # G-5642M 11186R). Kansas City, MO: Author.
American Journal of Nursing (1997). AJN/Mosby: Nursing boards review for NCLEX-RN (10th ed). St. Louis: Mosby.
American Journal of Nursing (1997). AJN/Mosby: Question and answer book for the NCLEX-RN (5th ed). St. Louis: Mosby.
*Student should have text from a prior course.
CLINICAL HOURS:
Seminar and conference hours according to schedule. Attendance at post-conference and seminars mandatory.
Clinical hours to be arranged based on preceptor schedule.
ALLOCATION OF TIME:
Nursing 444 requires 12 hours of clinical experience each week, or 120 hours total for the quarter. One of the 12 hours of clinical experience each week is a clinical conference. Nursing 444 requires 1 seminar hour each week.
SELECTED CLINICAL CLINICAL SEMINAR
EXPERIENCE CONFERENCE
(including project leadership/management)
WEEK 11 hours 1 hour 1 hour
QUARTER 110 hours 10 hours 10 hours
QUALIFICATIONS, ROLE, AND RESPONSIBILITIES
OF CLINICAL PRECEPTOR
Definition of Preceptor: A preceptor is a competent, proficient or expert level registered nurse with a special area of expertise who is assigned or volunteers to help a novice or advanced beginner level nursing student. The preceptor guides and facilitates the student through the learning activities required to achieve the clinical course objectives. The preceptor actively participates in the evaluation of a students clinical performance, though the final judgment always rests with the faculty member for the course.
Qualifications of Preceptor: The educational level and clinical expertise of the preceptor should be greater than the student. Therefore, the education preparation for preceptors of baccalaureate students should be a BSN or higher degree and for masters students a MSN or higher degree. The minimal clinical experience expected is two years of full-time employment in the special clinical area. This does not have to be two years with a specific organization. The preceptor must have a clear, current, active RN license in California. A contract must exist between CSU, Bakersfield and the preceptors healthcare agency or agency with a health component. The nurse executive or agency executive must agree to the employee serving as a preceptor.
Nomination of Preceptor: A preceptor can be identified by the following people: faculty member, student, self, nurse executive of a healthcare agency or agency with a health component, other preceptor. The preferred method of nomination of a preceptor is to complete the Preceptor Nomination form and submit it to Department of Nursing or the designated faculty member for the course. Nominations can also be made by verbal communication, such as telephone or written communication, such as e-mail, FAX, letter, or note. In these situations the Preceptor Nomination form should be completed by the faculty member or office personnel.
Preceptor Role and Responsibilities:
The preceptor functions as a resource person, facilitator, clinical role model, educator, and consultant to the student. The primary role is to provide a learning environment where the student can meet course and individual learning objectives.
The responsibilities of the preceptor are to:
1. Assist the student by arranging opportunities and resources to obtain learning experience appropriate to the course and individual learning objectives.
2. Assist the student in developing his or her learning objectives. This will include advising the student of possible learning opportunities.
3. Sign the students individual learning objectives following negotiation for appropriate learning experiences.
4. Assist the student in his or her orientation to the agency. This includes philosophy, policies and procedures of the agency and expectations of the student. Examples include- dress code, special equipment, emergency situations (fire, disaster, and codes), documentation, charting, medication administration and documentation, access to computer system for nursing documentation and retrieval of information, telephone and facsimile use.
5. Availability during the same schedule as the student. In most situations the student will need to match the preceptor schedule rather than the other way around. In rare situations, the preceptor may designate another agency member to assist the student. Designee must be an RN with sufficient experience to assist the student.
6. Sign the clinical timesheet verifying student attendance.
7. Provide ongoing and culminating evaluation on the students performance to the student and the assigned faculty member.
8. Meet with the student during the 5th week (midterm) and 10th week (final, end of term) to discuss and document student achievement or lack of achievement of course and individual learning objectives. This is documented on the student learning contract.
9. Notify the student and faculty member at any time during the course that a course or individual learning objective is not passed or when a student has not made sufficient progress toward reaching an objective.
10. Evaluate the students learning, in conjunction with the faculty, based on the course and individual learning objectives.
11. Evaluate the preceptor experience for the course.
12. Evaluate the preceptor orientation.
The descriptions of novice, advanced beginner, competent, proficient and expert are located in Benner, P., Tanner, C.A., & Chesla, C.A. (1996). Expertise in nursing practice: Caring, clinical judgment and ethics. New York: Springer.
QUALIFICATIONS, ROLE, AND RESPONSIBILITIES
OF STUDENT
Definition of Student: A CSU, Bakersfield nursing student is enrolled in the course and has met the prerequisite and corequisite requirements. A nursing student is at the novice or advanced beginner level (Benner, Tanner & Chesla, 1996). The student has ultimate responsibility for achieving the learning activities required to meet the clinical course objectives. The student actively participates in the learning of clinical performance skills. The preceptor and assigned faculty guide and facilitate the students learning and provide periodic and final evaluation of the students performance.
Qualifications of Student: The nursing student in Nursing 444 will have completed the beginning nursing courses in the areas of fundamental skills, medical and surgical, geriatric, maternity, pediatrics, and psychiatric/ mental health nursing. All students will have taken or be concurrently enrolled in community health nursing theory. All students must have the CSUB health clearance, malpractice insurance and completed the annual OSHA and CPR requirements. Some students will have completed the community health nursing experience. Some students will already be Registered Nurses. Most students will take the NCLEX (RN licensing examination) upon completion of all baccalaureate degree requirements (BSN graduation).
Selection of Clinical Experience and Preceptor: Students complete an information sheet prior to beginning Nursing 444. The information includes personal data, present and past employment, description and rationale for selected clinical experience and availability to nominate a preceptor. Students are not to have clinical experience in Nursing 444 in the agency where they are employed. This is to avoid role confusion between a student role and an employee role. Students are not to be paid for the clinical experience of Nursing 444.
A preceptor can be identified by the following people: faculty member, student, self, nurse executive of a healthcare agency or agency with a health component, other preceptor.
Student Role and Responsibilities:
The primary role of the student is to develop professional skills with an emphasis on clinical and leadership/management. The students focus is on learning activities to meet course and individual learning objectives.
The responsibilities of the student are to:
1. Prepare a learning contract with individual learning and course objectives, based on consultation and negotiation with the preceptor and assigned faculty.
2. Assure that signatures are obtained for the learning contract by the second week of the quarter and final signatures by the tenth week of the quarter.
3. Function within the framework of the assigned agency.
4. Participate in the orientation to the agency. This includes philosophy, policies and procedures of the agency. Examples include- dress code, special equipment, emergency situations (fire, disaster, and codes), documentation, charting, medication administration and documentation, access to computer system for nursing documentation and retrieval of information, telephone and facsimile use.
5. Develop a clinical experience schedule that matches the preceptors schedule and meets the required number of clinical hours without doing more than 16 hours in any one week. Observation related to the clinical objectives can be included in the schedule but are limited to eight hours or less for the entire quarter.
6. Assure preceptors signature on the clinical timesheet for each occasion of clinical experience.
7. Arrange for ongoing and culminating evaluation by the preceptor and the assigned faculty member.
8. Meet with the preceptor during the 5th week (midterm) and 10th week (final, end of term) to discuss and assure preceptor documentation of the achievement or lack of achievement of course and individual learning objectives. This is documented on the student learning contract.
9. Notify the preceptor and faculty member when not making sufficient progress toward reaching an objective or failing an objective.
10. Notify the preceptor and the assigned faculty member whenever an incident report is completed based on student error for a patient assigned to the student, such as a medication error or patient fall.
11. Notify the preceptor and assigned faculty member whenever a change in the clinical schedule is necessary, or clinical absence occurs. Notification of absence is to be made as early as reasonable and follow the Department of Nursing excused absence policy.
12. Maintain regular communications with the preceptor and assigned faculty member.
13. Provide opportunities for the preceptor and faculty to evaluate your progress in meeting individual learning and course objectives.
14. Evaluate the agency, preceptor and faculty member using the university and department provided forms.
15. Meet the requirements of the course through completion of course assignments.
The descriptions of novice, advanced beginner, competent, proficient and expert are located in Benner, P., Tanner, C.A., & Chesla, C.A. (1996). Expertise in nursing practice: Caring, clinical judgment and ethics. New York: Springer.
QUALIFICATIONS, ROLE, AND RESPONSIBILITIES
OF FACULTY
Definition of Faculty: An employee of CSU, Bakersfield and employed within the Department of Nursing. The nursing faculty member has to meet the university and department requirements for educational and clinical experience. A faculty member is at the competent, proficient or expert level (Benner, Tanner & Chesla, 1996). The faculty has ultimate responsibility for identifying clinical course objectives, course assignments and evaluation of students. The nursing faculty facilitate the learning environment for the student through coordination with the agency and the preceptor. The preceptor and assigned faculty guide and facilitate the students learning and provide periodic and final evaluation of the students performance. The faculty member retains ultimate responsibility for the evaluation of the student.
Qualifications of Faculty: Nursing faculty meet the educational, clinical and scholarly expectations of the university and department. Each nursing faculty must have a current, active and clear California RN license, meet expectations of the CSUB Department of Nursing health clearance, and have completed the annual OSHA and CPR requirements. Each nursing faculty member has an area of clinical expertise that is approved by the California Board of Registered Nursing. Some faculty have a California Public Health Certificate and some have national certification in a clinical specialty area. Some faculty are approved by the California Board of Registered Nursing as Nurse Practitioners and /or Clinical Nurse Specialists.
Selection of Nursing Faculty: Nursing faculty are assigned to courses based on their teaching and clinical experience. Faculty assigned to Nursing 444 will have a broad range of clinical experience but the primary focus will be medical, surgical, and community health nursing.
Selection of Clinical Experience and Preceptor: The nursing faculty in Nursing 444 have the ultimate responsibility for assignment of students to the clinical area and selection of preceptors. Based on the students information sheet and ranking of technical skills, availability of preceptors, agency agreement and contract, and consideration of the overall number of students assigned to an agency and area, the Nursing 444 faulty will assign each student to a clinical experience. Students will not be assigned to an agency or clinical area where they are employed.
A preceptor can be identified by the following people: faculty member, student, self, nurse executive of a healthcare agency or agency with a health component, other preceptor. Preceptors are assigned by the Nursing 444 faculty. In most cases a preceptor will only have one student assigned in a quarter. Preceptors must have completed the preceptor orientation and sign the preceptor agreement form.
Faculty Role and Responsibilities:
The primary role of the faculty is to plan the course, facilitate a learning environment for students, evaluate students in collaboration with the preceptor, and evaluate student assignments. The facultys focus is on assuring student learning activities to meet course and individual learning objectives.
The responsibilities of the faculty are to:
1. Prepare the course syllabus, including course objectives and assignments.
2. Obtain student information sheets for each student planning to take Nursing 444.
3. Provide an orientation for preceptors.
4. Assure that the University has a contract with each selected clinical agency.
5. Collaborate with agency administration in student clinical placement.
6. Assign students to the clinical experience.
7. Assign a preceptor for each student in Nursing 444.
8. Provide an orientation for nursing students.
9. Provide guidance in the student selection of individual learning objectives.
10. Facilitate ongoing and culminating student evaluation by the preceptor.
11. Communicate regularly with the preceptor and student.
12. Notify the preceptor and student when the student is not making sufficient progress toward reaching an objective or failing an objective.
13. Visit the clinical agency on a regular basis to observe the students performance and discuss progress with the student and preceptor.
14. Notify preceptors and students of any faculty absences and the designated faculty during the absence.
15. Arrange for another agency and preceptor if it is determined that the learning environment is not suitable for a student to obtain individual learning or course objectives.
16. Evaluate the agency, preceptor and student using the university and department provided forms.
17. Grade student assignments and provide written evaluation for each student based on the quality of the assignment.
18. Assign the final course grade to each student.
The descriptions of novice, advanced beginner, competent, proficient and expert are located in Benner, P., Tanner, C.A., & Chesla, C.A. (1996). Expertise in nursing practice: Caring, clinical judgment and ethics. New York: Springer.
SELECTED CLINICAL:
1. Students are to do their clinical experience in a hospital (agency) other than where they are employed. This is necessary to ensure that the student remain in a student role rather than that of an employee. It is the students responsibility to notify faculty of any employee role conflict.
2. Under no circumstances are student to be paid for the clinical experience.
3. Students are to do no more than 16 hours of selected clinical experience per week.
4. Clinical experience can include some observation but the major focus of the course is on student application of the leadership/management and clinician roles in a selected clinical area. Observation should be limited to eight hours or less for the entire course.
5. Selected clinical experience is scheduled to correspond to the preceptors schedule.
6. Faculty are available by telephone, e-mail and pager communication. In cases of faculty absence, telephone message will indicate an alternative available faculty member.
7. Faculty make rounds to the clinical settings to talk with students and clinical preceptors. Students are expected to be in the clinical setting on the days and times specified in the information submitted to faculty. If any change or variation in the schedule occurs, faculty must be notified to avoid an unexcused absence should faculty visit the setting according to the schedule and not find the student present.
8. Students are to contact the supervising faculty by telephone, e-mail or pager to notify the faculty of any changes in their schedule, absences, clinical problems, or need for faculty at the agency during the clinical hours.
ASSIGNMENTS AND EVALUATION:
There are four graded assignments and five pass or fail assignments due during the quarter:
Assignment % Final Grade Due Date
1. Written Notice to Faculty of Pass-Fail Conference-2nd week
Clinical and Project Schedule and
Calendar of Clinical Hours (App. A)
2. Learning Contract/Clinical Pass-Fail Conference-2nd week(submitted)
Course Objective (App. B)
(including individual learning
objectives
3. Clinical Evaluation/Learning Pass-Fail Conference-last week(completed)
Contract
4. Timesheets (App. C) Pass-Fail Submitted at conference on
week 3, 6 and 9
Submitted by last day of quarter (completed)
5. Clinical Conference and Seminar 10% See schedule
participation (App. D)
6. Response/Reflection 45% Submit by 3rd, 6th and 9th weeks Communications(App. E) of quarter
7. Written Report of the 30% Conference and seminar - week 8
Leadership/Management Project
(App. F and G)
8. Verbal Report of the 15% Date, time, location and group
Leadership/Management Project to be arranged by student and
(App. H) approved by faculty must occur prior to week 9
9. Pass RN license examination
(NCLEX) or acceptable nationally Pass-Fail Submitted by last day
normed test(Mosby RN of quarter
Assess Test)
For a detailed discussion of the requirements for each assignment, see the appendixes noted parenthetically above.
WRITTEN NOTICE TO FACULTY OF CLINICAL AND PROJECT SCHEDULE
AND CALENDAR OF CLINICAL HOURS
No later than the second conference and seminar, each student should submit to the faculty a written notice of the clinical agency setting, clinical hours, preceptor at the selected clinical site and the telephone number where the student may be reached in the agency. In addition, for the project component of the course, each student shall identify the project setting, project title, contact person and telephone number, and the names of all the students contributing to the group project. The notice shall be submitted by completing Appendix A. A passing grade is assigned for completing and submitting Appendix A with complete information, approval signatures, and following N444 course requirements no later than the second conference and seminar. A failing grade is assigned if Appendix A is not complete and/or not submitted.
LEARNING CONTRACT: CLINICAL COURSE OBJECTIVES
Each student shall develop a written learning contract for the selected clinical experience. Students are to add their individual learning objectives to the course objectives (Appendix B). The contract will identify the students individual learning objectives and the outcome criteria by which the student, preceptor, and the faculty can determine whether the objectives have been met. A minimum of two clinical skill objectives and two management/leader skill objectives must be included in the individual learning objectives. The content of the contract must be negotiated by the student with the preceptor and the faculty. The learning contract must be signed by the preceptor and submitted to faculty no later than the second clinical conference and seminar.
The student, preceptor, and faculty shall each receive a signed copy of the contract. The student is accountable for ensuring that the contract is signed and copies are received by the preceptor and the faculty by the due date.
Students are not to start the clinical practice prior to the facultys approval of the learning contract, but can start clinical orientation.
The contract (course objectives and individual learning objectives) will serve as the Pass-Fail evaluation tool for the student performance in the selected clinical experience portion of the course.
A passing grade is assigned to the learning contract for completing and submitting Appendix B (including individual learning objective) to the assigned faculty no later than the second conference and seminar. The individual learning objectives must meet the requirements described in the syllabus and be at senior baccalaureate nursing level. To achieve a passing grade, the student must meet criteria level 3, 4, or 5 for the course objectives and individual learning objectives.
CLINICAL EVALUATION
The learning contract will be evaluated by the faculty and the preceptor in the clinical setting. Students will be held accountable for obtaining a completed and signed learning contract
(Appendix B) from the preceptor and submitting it to faculty by last conference and seminar. NO GRADE will be given for the course UNTIL the student submits a completed learning contract signed and dated by the preceptor.
The date, initial, and pass/fail section of the learning contract is to be completed by your preceptor at the selected clinical site. The student is to notify the preceptor when an objective has been met and obtain the necessary documentation (date, initial of preceptor, and either pass or fail indication).
The typewritten format for the learning contract is in Appendix B. The learning contract includes the individual learning objectives and the clinical course objectives.
In order to receive a passing letter grade for the course, the student must receive a "pass" grade on each item of the learning contract (clinical course objectives and individual learning objectives). If a student receives a "fail" grade on any item, he/she has failed the course regardless of other grades earned. Students will be evaluated in the clinical area on preparedness and performance of skills, patient care, communication skills, and written requirements.
CLINICAL TIMESHEET
The clinical timesheet is located in Appendix C. At the end of each day of selected clinical experience, the timesheet is to be signed by the preceptor in your clinical area. Submit the timesheet at the conference on week 3, 6 and 9 of the course. Failure to submit your timesheet as required can result in a failure of the course. In order to receive a passing grade, the clinical cumulative hours must total 110 hours by the last day of the quarter.
The absence policy for the Department of Nursing will be in effect. All excused absences over 12 hours must be made up before the end of the quarter. Notify the preceptor and faculty of any clinical absence before you are due at the clinical site. All unexcused absences must be made up before the end of the quarter. Any unexcused absence can result in a failure of the course.
The clinical hours are based on 50-minute clock-hours. Students are expected to take their breaks and meal-time accordingly.
INDIVIDUAL STUDENT-FACULTY CONFERENCES:
Individual conferences are arranged on an as-needed basis. Faculty visit the various settings in which students have clinical experiences. The preceptor is continuously available when the student is in the clinical setting. Students are independently responsible for seeking out faculty when problems or questions arise. The telephone should be used liberally to contact faculty.
CLINICAL CONFERENCE AND SEMINAR PARTICIPATION
1. Attendance at the clinical conference and seminar is part of the course and is expected. An attendance sheet will be circulated during the conference and seminar to facilitate record keeping. Students must notify the faculty of absence prior to the conference and seminar.
2. The excused/unexcused policy of the Department of Nursing will be followed.
3. Faculty members retain the right to assign alternative experiences to make up for excused absences.
4. Each clinical conference and seminar absence will result in a ten percent reduction on the conference and seminar participation score.
5. Five or more excused or unexcused absences from the conference or seminar will constitute a failure in the course.
RESPONSE/REFLECTION COMMUNICATIONS
The response/reflection communications shall be submitted to the assigned faculty by the clinical conference and seminar of the 3rd, 6th and 9th week of the quarter.
Each submission shall include the following information: student name and date of submission.
Literature Review Responses/Reflections: One review of literature per week for a total of 8. The literature review must be related to your selected clinical experience or leadership/management project. One of the articles reviewed must address an ethical dilemma/issue or an ethical case study. Two of the articles must be research based. Textbooks are not sufficient to meeting this requirement. Submit two communications by the 3rd week of quarter, three communications by the 6th week of quarter and three communications by the 9th week of quarter.
Clinical Responses/Reflections: Clinical communications must include observation and reflection on your progress toward course objectives through the clinical experience. Problems and successes should also be reflected in your communications. It is a major form of communication between you and the faculty. All clients should be referred to by use of initials in order to maintain confidentiality. In your clinical communication, identify ethical, legal, economic, and political issues related to your experience. You are to include current media (newspaper, articles, magazines) when responding to the issues related to your experience. It is expected that you will write a response/reflection communication following each clinical experience.
Leadership/Management Project Responses/Reflections: Project communications include observation and reflection on your progress toward course objectives through conduct of the project. Includes problems, successes, quandaries. Include the time spent on the project. It is expected that you will write a response/reflection communication for each week of the quarter.
Grading is 15% for literature review, 15% for clinical and 15% for leadership/management project responses/reflections. Grading is based on the quality of the writing (grammar, spelling); demonstration of critical thinking/evaluative ability; identification of legal and ethical responsibilities, and demonstration of advanced beginning clinical knowledge. Communications are expected to be at a professional colleague level. Communication with the assigned faculty is a major responsibility of each student. Lack of regular communication can result in failure of the course.
LEADERSHIP/MANAGEMENT PROJECT:
1. The leadership/management project is a group accomplishment. These groups can consist of 3-5 students. Exceptions to the number of students in a group may be made with permission of faculty. A peer evaluation will be used to determine the extent of participation within the group. Based on the "within group peer evaluation" score, the individual students written assignment grade will be adjusted. The "within group peer evaluation" score adjustment is as follows:
A = no change in grade
B = minus 4 points
C = minus 8 points
D = minus 12 points
F = minus 16 points or no credit for the assignment
2. An outline of the proposed project must be submitted for approval to the supervising faculty prior to the planning. Approval must be received from the agency and/or unit to implement the project. This approval must be submitted to the supervising faculty.
3. The project must be based on a needs assessment conducted by the students or by the agency. The planning, implementation, and evaluation phases of this project must be competed by the end of the quarter in which the student is enrolled.
4. Examples of possible project topics are attached. Discussions about the project will occur during some of the conference and seminar sessions.
5. A verbal report of the project is made to an appropriate group of nurses. If appropriate, the group could include interdisciplinary members. The supervising faculty approves the group, date, time and place for the verbal report.
WRITTEN REPORT OF THE LEADERSHIP/MANAGEMENT PROJECT
Each student shall implement a leadership/management project during the quarter. A paper derived from this project will be due no later than the 8th conference and seminar of the quarter. The grade for this report will constitute 30% of the course grade. The evaluation criteria for the project written report is in Appendix F.
Students are expected to complete or assist with a needs assessment, implement the project and evaluate its effectiveness. This project will be based on a proposal submitted to and approved by the agency concerned, the agency preceptor and the supervising faculty. The proposal may be modified, in consultation with the faculty, to fit within the time frame of the professional nursing practicum.
Students will collaborate on this particular project. When students collaborate, the final product shall reflect the efforts of each group member. It is advisable that group members maintain close editorial control over one anothers work to avoid disappointments if one or more members submit work of a lesser quality than is expected. Appendix G is the within group peer evaluation. This is submitted by each student in a sealed envelope with the paper. Student comments are necessary to support ratings of "limited" or "no evidence."
The final project report shall be written in standard project format. (See guidelines in the Suggested Outline for Written Project Report and Grading Considerations.)
Submit 2 copies of the paper (if you want one back) and a copy of each reference cited (including specific page from books with the source clearly identified.) There is no need to submit copies of references from the required texts. Papers will not be graded and treated as late papers until a copy of each cited reference is submitted. Submit all documents in a single folder/envelope. Five percentage points will be subtracted for every day the paper is late.
OUTLINE FOR WRITTEN LEADERSHIP/MANAGEMENT PROJECT REPORT
TITLE
Abstract
INTRODUCTION
Assessment of the problem
Background and significance of the problem identified
Purpose of the project
Goal of the project
REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE
Review of appropriate journals and research relevant to the identified problem
Synthesis of the literature review
METHODOLOGY
Assessment of need
Diagnosis of problem
Project Plan
Goals
Objectives
IMPLEMENTATION
Barriers
Positive Aspects
Group member responsibilities
EVALUATION
Effectiveness of Project
Goal achievement
Specific results and findings
Conclusions
RECOMMENDATIONS
IMPLICATIONS FOR NURSING ROLES (Clinician, Educator, Researcher and Leader)
REFERENCES
APPENDICES
Approvals (agency, resource person, faculty)
Timelines
Gantt charts
Tools
Evaluation form
VERBAL PRESENTATION OF PROJECT
The criteria for grading of the verbal presentations is in Appendix H.
The following are considerations and inclusion criteria for the evaluation of the verbal presentation.
1. Title of project, introduction of group members, and problem identification.
2. Summary of review of literature.
3. Methodology
4. Implementation
5. Evaluation
6. Recommendations
7. Implications for Nursing Role
8. Clarity of information and organization of material
9. Handouts
10. Professional appearance and behavior of students
11. Students ability to answer queries from audience
During Verbal Presentation:
1. Have an abstract handout available for those attending presentation. Include the title and names of the students on the abstract.
2. All students must be present and participate in the verbal presentation.
3. Include time to answer questions of those attending.
ABILITY TO SUCCESSFULLY PASS NCLEX (RN LICENSE EXAMINATION)
A culminating expectation of the baccalaureate of nursing program is that each student can demonstrate the ability to successfully pass the RN license examination (NCLEX). This can be demonstrated by two methods.
1. Providing a copy of a valid, active California RN license. Other state RN licenses will also be accepted.
2. Passing the Secured Mosby RN Assessment test with a percentile ranking of 33 or above relative to RN norm group. Other nationally normed test will be accepted on an individual basis if taken within the previous six months. For other tests, the assigned faculty will set an equivalent percentile ranking for passing.
There are four comprehensive tests. Each test consists of 75 questions. Clinical and seminar conference two and four will be used for the test. You will need to plan to come either one hour early or one hour after the conference/seminar time so that two tests can be completed on each day.
Costs for all four comprehensive tests is $35.00. Checks to CSUB are due on the date of the first test.
The NCLEX-RN Test Plan is on reserve in the library.
If you do not attain a percentile ranking of 33 or above on the test, you must retake the test on your own time. The dates faculty are available to give the tests a second time will be arranged between the faculty members and the students. An additional cost of $35.00 will be necessary for students needing to retake the test.
If you do not demonstrate the ability to successfully pass NCLEX, you will receive a grade of C- or below(not passing) for Nursing 444.
CLINICAL ABSENCE:
Selected Clinical Experience
Students can have no more than 12 hours of excused clinical absence from their selected clinical experience. Students are to notify the faculty covering for the designated time period and also notify the preceptor or their designee at the selected clinical site. The student needs to obtain a faculty signature on their clinical time sheet for the excused absence. Unexcused absences are not acceptable and may result in failure of the course. Excused absences in excess of 12 hours and all unexcused absences must be made up by the last day of the quarter. Arrangements for making up for clinical hours is at the discretion of the faculty and preceptor.
ORIGINAL WORK:
All work must be original work written for this course by the individual submitting it. See definition of plagiarism according to the University General Catalogue and the Department of Nursing Student Handbook. The penalty for plagiarism is an "F" in the course for first offense and termination from the University for second offense. If any questions, ask your advisor.
GRADING SCALE:
The grading scale of the Department of Nursing will be used in this course. All written work will follow the Department of Nursing guidelines. No grades will be rounded up.
Percentage Grading Scale
A 93-100 C 73-76
A- 90-92 C- 70-72
B+ 87-89 D+ 67-69
B 83-86 D 63-66
B- 80-82 D- 60-62
C+ 77-79 F 59 or below
A grade of C (73) or better is required to pass a nursing course.
EXAMPLES OF POSSIBLE LEADERSHIP/MANAGEMENT PROJECT TOPICS
Time Management Project
Objectives: To enable the student to:
Apply the steps of the management process
Analyze the ways that time can be managed
Compare activity time needs in relation to available time resources
Determine productivity of workers
Evaluate non-productive time use
Activities: The time management project will take place in any health care facility. The student will work with a nurse-manager preceptor on any of the following projects:
The use of a managers time: analysis of interruptions, how priorities are set by the manager, how goals are achieved. Tools such as PERT analysis, or Gantt charts may be used. The student should also note the delegation process: how the manager delegates, what projects are delegated, how the delegatee is selected, and how the manager follows the project. Meetings are analyzed through the group process theory. The student(s) will present their findings in a paper that includes strengths and weaknesses of the activities analyzed, and suggestions for improvement of time management processes addressed.
Staffing Project
Objectives: To enable the student to:
Incorporate steps identified in systems theory
Recognize the synthesis of the agency mission into staffing policies
Identify health care and societal trends that influence staffing policies and practices
Activities: Working with a nurse-manager preceptor, the student plans the staffing of a hospital unit, home health unit, SNF, or community health facility. It would be enlightening to analyze the staffing of all of these facilities in order to determine how different patient needs, acuities, and staff skill mix influence staffing decisions. The student would need to analyze variations in the patient census and acuity, determine the average daily census, the average length of stay of patients with various medical diagnoses, the weight of each patient DRG, and note seasonal variations in admissions for particular diagnoses. Note types of care given: hands-on, indirect care, health teaching. The student would need to identify types of patients, needed nursing activities for those patients, and project the time that would be needed to perform those activities.
Nursing Management Process Projects
Objectives: Upon completion of these projects, the student will be able to:
Analyze the culture of a workplace, using a guide formulated from
del Brunos article
Discuss the role of organizational environment and culture
Describe organizational structure in terms of organizational theory
Compare and contrast the different types of organizational structures
Discuss the types of interorganizational relationships
Discuss the advantages of participative management styles, such as shared
governance
Suggested activities:
Culture Analysis:
The student, with a nurse-manager preceptor would formulate a questionnaire to distribute to the staff of a health care organization or organizations. This questionnaire could incorporate questions that would include the work, the environment, and the relationships between staff.
Organizational Structure:
The student(s) analysis of the organizational chart in order to identity relationships between staff and management.
Organizational Theory:
The staff and management attitudes toward change, both overt and covert can be analyzed. As the student works with the preceptor, values and beliefs of the institution would be formulated, using the philosophy and mission statements of the institution. The student would need to determine how these values and beliefs were derived from our larger society, and how these beliefs influence the health care services offered to the community. Several students or groups of students could work in several agencies, then compare their results to see how the philosophies and care offered by these agencies differ. Is the management of the organization best described by Weber, (bureaucracy); MacGregor (X & Y); Simon (Economic man or administrative man), etc.
Leadership Styles:
Leadership styles of the various managers can be analyzed, either through observation, staff feed-back, or self-analysis of the manager, using a questionnaire such as the Firo-B. The cognitive styles of various managers could be analyzed -- how does the manager problem solve, think, perceive, remember? Resource: (Witkin, H.A., Goodenough, D.R. (1982). Cognitive styles: Essence and origins. New York: International Universities Press.) The student(s) can compare the styles of overall leadership and management with existing management styles (MBO, shared governance, etc.) The student could formulate a plan to introduce a participative style, such as a shared governance, into an organization.
The role of licensing and accreditation agencies, such as state health departments, or JCAHO can be incorporated into the overall analysis of an organization.
The agency activities can be analyzed according to: clientele (demographics and use patterns), agency services (type, scope, depth, stages of care), research activities of the agency (funding, approval process, who participates in these activities), educational programs, and power structure (analysis of the formal structure, sociograms, impact of power.)
The student(s) can take note of acceptance of the expanded nursing role in the facility (nurse practitioner, clinical nurse specialist). How much influence or authority do these nurses have in the hospital or community agency?
Staff Selection Project
Objectives: At the end of this project, the student would be able to:
Describe the recruitment and selection process
Explain job analysis
Discuss legal issues in hiring
Analysis of the interview process
Activities: Working with a nurse-manager preceptor, the student will participate in an analysis of the steps in hiring and orienting new staff.
Recruitment and Selection:
Several students can work with different health care organizations such as an acute care hospital, SNF, or community health agency. With the preceptor, the student will need to perform a job analysis. From this analysis, an interview guide will be planned. IF the preceptor is willing, the student could be present at actual job interviews, or could analyze interview with the preceptor. The decision-making process would be discussed. Possible decisions such as to select a certain applicant, reopen the search, or train someone in-house for the position would be considered. Questions for the student to consider: How did the opening come about? What were the qualifications of the person who held the job before? Is this a new position? How and why was it created? Are there influences, such as personality or dress, that influence the outcome of the interview? How is a "match" between the organization and the applicant determined? How is the job advertised?
Quality Improvement
Objectives: Upon completing this project, the student will be able to:
Describe Quality Improvement
Discuss nursings role in quality improvement
Formulate indicators and outcome standards for study
Activities: The student, working with a nursing CQI manager or group, will analyze the nursing standards formulated for a health care institution. The student will: identify a suitable topic for a patient care CQI study. Working with all those involved with the care (pharmacy, medicine, RT, PT, etc.), at least three criteria will be formulated with outcome standards. The group will agree on how the study is to be conducted and then the student, working always in cooperation with the other providers, will conduct the study over a designated period of time and report the findings and proposed corrective actions to the appropriate committee. The student could also work as a facilitator to assist with corrective actions (system corrections, staff education, etc.)
Steps would need to be taken to assure confidentiality of all findings and outcomes.
NURSING 444, PROFESSIONAL NURSING PRACTICUM
APPENDIX A
WRITTEN NOTICE TO FACULTY OF CLINICAL AND PROJECT
SCHEDULE AND CALENDAR OF
CLINICAL HOURS
STUDENT NAME: ___________________________________________________________
STUDENT TELEPHONE # : Home: ___________________ Other: ___________________
CLINICAL SETTING:
Unit Within the Agency: ___________________________________________________
Unit telephone number: ___________________________________________________
Name of Preceptor: _______________________________________________________
Clinical Hours: __________________________________________________________
(A calendar of clinical hours may be attached if day and time vary.)
PROJECT SETTING:
Project Title __________________________________________________________
Project Location __________________________________________________________
Approvals:
1. Agency ____________________________________ Date approved _____________
Telephone # ______________________
2. Resource Person ____________________________ Date ____________________
Telephone # _______________________
3. Faculty ___________________________________ Date ____________________
Names of all student collaborating on project _________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
Verbal report of the project:
Group _______________________________
Date/Time ____________________________
Location _____________________________
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, BAKERSFIELD
Department of Nursing
Student/Name _____________________________ Instructor ____________________________
Course __________________________________ Date ________________________________
Evaluation will be based on the degree to which the student meets the course objectives as they are delineated by the criteria state in this evaluation tool.
A. To achieve a passing grade, the student must meet the criteria in one of the following ways:
5. Independent performance:
Performance safely and accurately each time without supportive cues from preceptor or instructor. Demonstrates dexterity and spends minimal time on task.
Focuses on client.
Applies theoretical knowledge each time.
4. Supervised performance:
Performs safely and accurately each time, requires supportive cues occasionally during performance of tasks.
Demonstrates coordination, and spends reasonable time on task.
Focuses on client with some focus on task.
Applies theoretical knowledge with occasional cues.
3. Assisted performance:
Performs safely and accurately each time, requires frequent supportive and occasional directive cues.
Demonstrates partial lack of dexterity.
Focuses primarily on task or own behavior, not on client.
can identify principles but needs direction to coordinate with application.
B. A student fails the objectives if any of the following are indicated:
2. Provisional performance:
Performs safely under close supervision. Not always accurate, requires continuous supportive, and directive cues.
Demonstrates lack of skill and/or performs tasks with considerable delay with omissions and delays.
Focuses entirely on task or own behavior.
Applies principles inappropriately or inadequately.
1. Dependent performance:
Performs in an unsafe manner, requires continuous supportive directions and cues.
Performs in an unskilled manner.
Attempts activity or behavior yet is unable to complete.
Focuses entirely on task or own behavior.
Unable to identify principles or apply them.
0. Negative pattern:
Demonstrates a pattern of unacceptable performances.
C. NSO indicated not sufficiently observed N indicates no opportunity
Adapted from Krichbaun (1983). Criterion referenced definitions, Journal of Nursing Education, 22, p. 376.
bbp 11/96
NURSING 444, PROFESSIONAL NURSING PRACTICUM
APPENDIX B
LEARNING CONTRACT: CLINICAL COURSE OBJECTIVES
FOR: _________________________________ AT: ________________________
| Clinical Area: | Date/Initial |
Level 0-5 |
NSO |
N |
| I. Perform nursing roles (clinician, educator, researcher and leader) at the beginning level of independent nursing practice while utilizing the CSUB Department of Nursing Conceptual Model. | ||||
| A. Documents the use of the nursing process in the care and management of patients. |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
| B. Demonstrates through the use of a nursing care plan the process for improving and revising the care of a specific client. |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
| C. Performs nursing skills that are entry level expectations in the selected clinical setting. |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
| D. Identifies the ANA Standards of Nursing for the specific clinical area. | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| II. Incorporate legal and ethical responsibilities into each of the nursing roles. | ||||
| A. Identifies legal issues for the specific clinical setting and mode. | ________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| B. Discusses ethical issues/concerns with the preceptor for the specific clinical experience. | _________ |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
| III. Collaborate with other members of the interdisciplinary team to promote client (individual, family, group, aggregate, or community) system stability. |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
| A. Attends multidisciplinary team meetings (rounds). | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| B. Documents multidisciplinary team meetings (rounds). | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| C. Sustains collaborative relationship with other health personnel. | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| IV. Utilize research in the professional nursing practice setting. | ||||
| A. Shares recent research relevant to the clinical practicum experience. | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| B. Suggests change in nursing practice based on nursing research. | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| C. Assesses or implements a change in nursing procedure based on nursing research. | _________ |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
| V. Apply critical thinking and evaluation skills of a beginning professional leader and advanced beginning clinician in the practice setting. | ||||
| A. Reports on the effectiveness (outcome) of nursing procedures. | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| B. Demonstrates critical thinking skills in staff assignments, delegation of assignment, and client management. | _________ |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
| C. Uses initiative to think through problems, examine alternatives, and make decisions within their capabilities. |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
| VI. Demonstrate professional behavior. | ||||
| A. Behaves consistently within the ANA Code of Nursing. | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| B. Follows Agency and departmental policies for the following: | ||||
| 1. Accurate recordkeeping, including spelling, abbreviations. | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| 2. Maintain confidentiality of records and client communication. | _________ |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
| 3. Use appropriate Agency forms. | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| 4. Follows policy for use of Agency equipment. | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| 5. Follows policy for use of Agency equipment. | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| 6. Arrives on time for clinical experience. | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| 7. Notifies preceptor and faculty of absence from clinical. | _________ | _________ | _________ | _________ |
| C. Informs resource person of progress and problems within the selected clinical experience. | _________ |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
| D. Informs faculty of progress and problems within the selected clinical experience. | _________ |
_________ |
_________ |
_________ |
| VII. Individual Objectives |
Agreement to learning contract:
Date ____________________ _________________________________________
Student
Date ____________________ _________________________________________
Preceptor
Date ____________________ _________________________________________
Faculty
NB: Students cannot begin the clinical practice other than orientation until all signatures have been obtained.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Completion of learning contract:
Date ____________________ _________________________________________
Student
Date ____________________ _________________________________________
Preceptor
Date ____________________ _________________________________________ Faculty
APPENDIX C
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, BAKERSFIELD
Department of Nursing
Nursing 444 - Professional Nursing Practicum
Clinical Timesheet for
________________________________________ Quarter _______ Year ______
Student Name
__________________________________ _______________________________
Agency Preceptor
Date of Experience |
Hours of Experience |
Preceptor or Faculty Signature |
Cumulative Hours |
The preceptor or designee will sign after the clinical hours have been completed on a particular day. The faculty will sign for any excused hours of clinical.
NURSING 444, PROFESSIONAL NURSING PRACTICUM
APPENDIX D
Calendar of Clinical Conferences and Seminars
CLINICAL CONFERENCE |
SEMINAR |
MONDAY 1800-1850 |
MONDAY 1900-1950 |
| January 11 Orientation to N444 |
January 11 Orientation to N444 Arrange for clinical experience Orientation to clinical |
| January 19 (Tuesday) Mosby Assess Test #1 Submit Appendix A and B |
January 19 (Tuesday) Mosby Assess Test #2 |
| January 25 Case management Submit Appendix C (timesheet) Submit Response/Reflection Communications |
January 25 Critical Thinking in Nursing P. Leapley |
| February 1 Mosby Assess Test #3 |
February 1 Mosby Assess Test #4 |
| February 8 Quality Assurance |
February 8 Time Management and Development of Clinical Skills |
| February 15 Critical Pathways/Interdisciplinary Collaboration Submit Appendix C (timesheet) Submit Response/Reflection Communications |
February 15 Staffing/Charge Nurse Responsibilities |
| February 22 Ethical Issues - case presentations |
February 22 Professional Leadership |
| March 1 Legal Issues - case presentations Submit written report of Leadership/Management Project |
March 1 Expertise in Nursing Practice S. Pfettscher |
| March 8 Economic/Political Issues-case presentations Submit Appendix C (timesheet) Submit Response/Reflection Communications |
March 8 Critical Thinking Skills Test |
| March 15 Course Evaluation |
March 15 Nursing Roles |
| March 16 by 4 p.m. (Last Day of Quarter) Signed Learning Contract (Appendix B) Completed Timesheet (Appendix C) Documentation of ability to be successful on NCLEX |
NURSING 444, PROFESSIONAL NURSING PRACTICUM
APPENDIX E
RESPONSE/REFLECTION
COMMUNICATIONS
Student __________________________________________
First (3rd Week) Second (6th Week) Third (9th Week)
| Responses/Reflections | 15% |
15% |
15% |
| Literature Review (5 points each time)* |
|
|
|
| Clinical (5 points each time) |
|
||
| Leadership/Management Project (5 points each time) |
|
|
|
| TOTAL |
*One ethical dilemma/issue or case study. Two research based.
NURSING 444, PROFESSIONAL NURSING PRACTICUM
APPENDIX F
EVALUATION OF PROJECT REPORT
Names of Project Group Members: ________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
Title of Leadership/Management Project: ____________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
Criteria for Evaluation Possible Points Student Points
1. Introduction: assessment of the 15
problem, background & significance
of problem, purpose of project & goals
2. Review of the Literature 10
3. Methodology: assessment of need, 15
diagnosis of problem, project plan
(goals, objectives)
4. Project implementation, identification 15
of barriers, positive aspects, group
members responsibilities
5. Evaluation: effectiveness & project, 20
goal achievement, results & findings,
conclusions
6. Recommendations 5
7. Implications for Nursing Roles 10
8. References & Appendices 10
9. APA format: problems with spelling
errors and grammar will result in
deductions of up to 100 points
___________ ___________
TOTAL: 100
Note: Plagiarism will result in an F for the paper and the course grade
NURSING 444, PROFESSIONAL NURSING PRACTICUM
APPENDIX G
Within Group Peer Evaluation
Title: ______________________________________________________________________
Date of Evaluation: ____________________ Name of Evaluator: ______________________
Names of other members of your group: ___________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Rating: 4 = Consistently outstanding Grading: 27-32 = A (no change)
3 = Usually very good 26-21 = B (minus 4 points)
2 = Average 15-20 = C (minus 8 points)
1 = Limited 9-14 = D (minus 12 points)
0 = No evidence 0-8 = F (minus 16 or no credit)
Student Participation |
Initials of Student |
Comments |
|||
Behavior |
|||||
| 1. Accepted responsibility for tasks of the assignment | |||||
| 2. Contributed relevant ideas to the assignment | |||||
| 3. Provided/Obtained resources necessary to complete the assignment | |||||
| 4. Demonstrated ability to compete tasks assigned by group that contribute to the quality of the assignment | |||||
| 5. Demonstrated commitment to the group effort by attending meetings | |||||
| 6. Completed written work using the correct format as determined by the group and the assignment requirements | |||||
| 7. Communicated with group members in a professional and timely fashion | |||||
| 8. Accepted accountability for seeking faculty guidance in completing the assignment | |||||
NURSING 444 - PROFESSIONAL NURSING PRACTICUM
APPENDIX H
EVALUATION OF VERBAL PRESENTATION OF PROJECT
GROUP HEARING PRESENTATION: __________________________________________
NAMES OF GROUP MEMBERS: ______________________________________________
TITLE OF PRESENTATION: _________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
DATE: ________________________ LOCATION: ____________________________
Criteria for Evaluation Possible Points Student Points
1. Title, introduction, problem identification 10
2. Summary of Review of Literature 5
3. Methodology 10
4. Implementation 5
5. Evaluation 10
6. Recommendations 10
7. Implications for Nursing Roles 10
8. Clarity of information and organization 10
of material
9. Handouts 10
10. Professional appearance/behavior of students 10
11. Ability to answer questions 10
_________ _________
TOTAL 100
COMMENTS: